There’s much speculation as to why girls incur a soccer concussion at a higher rate than boys – even though they both play the same types of sports (e.g. basketball, soccer, hockey, etc.).
Several theories exist and it seems that there’s not that much conclusive evidence to ether verify or negate most of them.
Here are some popular explanations:
1. Structure of the neck
Boys generally have a greater muscle mass and density in their necks than girls. It could be possible that this difference allows boys to handle and cushion a blow to the head more effectively – thereby diminishing the effect on the brain. Girls also are prone to rotating their heads much faster than boys – that could have something to do with it as well. So, does it make sense to have girls work on exercises to strengthen their necks?
Guess it could not hurt though there’s no proof it can be of any benefit. Me? I’d say yes – stretch and build those muscles, not much to lose.
SEE MORE: Concussions Caused By Soccer
2. Just Predisposed
There are differences between the brains of girls and boys – especially adolescent brains; this may lead to more concussions in soccer for girls. The effects of testosterone and estrogen, and its impact on brain function, could be contributing to more concussions in girls.
Hopefully a couple of new research studies will be conclusive enough to alter treatment and prevention of girls with soccer concussions (while also helping boys as well!).
3. More Likely to Report
Girls may be more likely to report the symptoms of a concussion. They could be more willing to talk to their coach, athletic director and parents than boys.
I’ve heard from many parents of soccer players that said if no one was around to witness the girls getting a concussion then she probably would not have said anything or reported it at all. Parents, coaches and trainers need to be better educated to help the kids realize what has just happened and it’s OK to be hurt – that’s how we can treat them!
If a boy has the same degree of pain and discomfort associated with a concussion he may be willing to live through it for fear of being labeled not tough enough to handle it or he may not want to risk missing a game or practice. No scientific proof of this but doesn’t it just make common sense?
Want More Information? SEE MORE: Concussions Caused By Soccer
Girls soccer players are more likely to suffer concussions than boys and they take longer to recover and many times have more symptoms too. Studies prove most of this too.
You should publish some of these concussions studies!
A boy’s neck is generally bigger and stronger than a girl’s and this adds protection for him anyway. I know sounds sexit but girls have less strength and ability to rotate their necks which I would think makes them more vulnerable.